November 17, 2026 · Maciej Barwinski
Is Prebiotic Soda Actually Good for Your Gut?
By Maciej Barwinski, founder of Brooklyn Cannery
Prebiotic sodas are everywhere right now. Bright cans, big promises, and "gut health" printed across the front. As someone who formulates and cans beverages for a living at our factory in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, I get asked all the time whether any of it is real.
My honest answer: prebiotic soda can be good for you, but probably not for the reason the marketing suggests. Here's what I've learned from making it myself.
Why I put prebiotics in our soda in the first place
The starting point was simple. A high-fibre diet is good for you, and most of us don't eat enough fibre. The more I read while developing Brooklyn Cannery, the more one idea stuck with me: a healthy gut microbiome is linked not just to digestion but to how we feel mentally. The science on the gut-brain connection is still developing, but it was enough to make me take the fibre side of our formula seriously instead of treating it as a label buzzword.
Not all prebiotic fibre is the same
This is the part most shoppers never hear about.
We use chicory root fibre, 5 grams per can. During development I looked at other options, including cheaper fibres like corn fibre. They cost less, but I didn't feel they were the same quality, and I didn't want to build the product on them. Chicory root gave us the best balance of taste and effectiveness.
Because we also manufacture drinks for other brands, I see what goes on behind the scenes. What I notice is that many bigger brands lean on cheaper, lower-quality inulin. It still lets them print "prebiotic" on the can, but the ingredient list doesn't tell you the whole story.
What to look for: check which fibre is used and how many grams are actually in the can. A vague "prebiotic blend" with no fibre amount listed should make you curious.
The real win: what's not in the can
Here's my honest take, even if it isn't the flashiest marketing line. The biggest health benefit of a good prebiotic soda isn't some dramatic change to your gut. It's that it replaces regular soda.
Look at the sugar:
|
|
Sugar per can |
Sweetened with |
|---|---|---|
|
Typical regular soda |
around 40 g |
cane sugar or high-fructose corn syrup |
|
Brooklyn Cannery |
6 g |
cane sugar, monk fruit and a little stevia |
Good prebiotic sodas generally have far less sugar and use real fruit juice. Swapping a 40-gram sugar habit for 6 grams, plus some fibre, is a meaningful improvement on its own.
What our customers tell us
One of the most rewarding things we've seen is Diet Coke drinkers switching to our Cola Amaretto. These are people who wanted the ritual of a cola without the sugar, and who found something they actually enjoy. That's the point: people stick with a healthier swap when it tastes great. The feedback we hear most is about the full flavour.
An honest warning: bloating
If you're not used to much fibre, you might feel some bloating at first. That's normal, and in my experience the body adjusts over time. Start with one can and see how you feel rather than drinking several in a day.
How to drink it
Prebiotic soda doesn't replace real food. My recommendation is to get your fibre from fruit, vegetables and whole foods first, and enjoy prebiotic soda as a treat alongside a meal. Think of it as an upgrade on the soda you'd have drunk anyway, not a supplement or a cure.
The bottom line
So, is prebiotic soda actually good for your gut? It can help, especially if it replaces sugary soda and uses quality fibre. But the real foundation is your plate.
If you remember one thing, make it this: eating real fruit and vegetables while enjoying a delicious prebiotic soda can be a good combination for a healthy gut, and maybe even a healthy mind.
This post shares my experience as a beverage maker and isn't medical advice. If you have digestive issues, talk to your doctor.
